Allegations of ties to app
The controversy began when Greenpeace and the Indonesian environmental NGO Auriga Nusantara petitioned the FSC in November to revoke Paper Excellence's certification. This petition followed an investigation by CBC News and other media outlets that suggested Paper Excellence had close operational and ownership ties to APP. APP, known for its history of rainforest destruction, lost its own FSC certification in 2007.
According to the investigation, Paper Excellence had been coordinating business decisions and sharing resources with APP until at least a few years ago. These allegations were backed by both the media reports and independent research by the environmental groups.
Fsc's controversial review process
The FSC's decision to retain Paper Excellence's certification hinged on a "corporate group review" conducted by McMillan LLP, a law firm frequently employed by Paper Excellence. This choice has sparked significant controversy. Greenpeace Canada’s program director, Shawn - Patrick Stensil, expressed shock that the FSC would hire a firm with such close ties to Paper Excellence, arguing this undermines the credibility of the review.
The FSC defended its decision, stating that a conflict of interest check was conducted before hiring McMillan LLP, and no conflicts were found. McMillan's CEO, Tim Murphy, echoed this sentiment, asserting that the firm adhered to all professional conduct rules and that no conflict existed.
Criticism from environmental groups and experts
Environmental groups were not convinced by the FSC's assurances. Auriga Nusantara's chairman, Timer Manurung, criticized the FSC for not disclosing the data used in the review, suggesting the analysis lacked comprehensive data. The FSC cited confidentiality and a non - disclosure agreement with Paper Excellence as reasons for withholding this information. Greenpeace's Stensil pointed out that the evidence used in the review was limited to public and corporate records, as well as documents provided by Paper Excellence. He argued that these sources were unlikely to reveal the true extent of control exercised by APP over Paper Excellence.
Legal ethics experts also weighed in, questioning the FSC's decision to hire McMillan LLP. Christina Bellon, a philosophy professor with expertise in ethics, highlighted the financial conflict of interest inherent in hiring a firm's own lawyers for such an assessment. Allan Hutchinson, a law professor and legal ethics author, agreed, noting that the review could not be considered independent given the circumstances.
Source: CBC.CA





In the world of high-end horology, trust is everything. Watchauren Trade was created for collectors who want to sell or exchange their luxury timepieces with confidence, clarity and zero hassle. Whether you're refining your collection or searching for the next grail watch, Watchauren offers a modern, expert-driven approach to trading fine watches.
There's something deeply compelling about dive watches that transcends their original purpose.
As Coldplay prepares for four concerts in Toronto this week, fans are expressing growing concerns about Rogers Stadium, the new 50,000-seat venue in the city’s north end. The British rock band is scheduled to perform from Monday to Saturday, but issues raised during the stadium's first major event have cast a shadow over the excitement.
Acne is one of the most common skin concerns, affecting people of all ages.
Six teams from around the world converged in Taipei on December 10, 2025, for the global finals of the “Go Healthy with Taiwan” Call for Proposals, culminating in the selection of three winning innovations poised to shape the future of global health. The competition attracted 638 proposals from 55 countries, underscoring Taiwan’s rising prominence as a hub for health technology and cross-border collaboration.
The MedsCheck program in Ontario has entered a period of intense scrutiny as newly released financial records and survey findings reveal significant billing increases and persistent pressure on pharmacists across major retail chains. The data shows a sharp escalation in MedsCheck revenues and highlights ongoing concerns surrounding corporate influence in pharmacy practice. These developments have renewed debate about the program’s design and the future of medication review services in the province.
Extrusion is one of the most versatile and cost-efficient manufacturing processes for producing continuous plastic and elastomer profiles. While it is often associated with large construction components like pipes, window frames, or decking boards, extrusion truly shines in the production of small, highly specialized profiles—the kind used in marine systems, technical assemblies, electronics, automotive interiors, sealing solutions, and custom industrial applications. These miniature or precision profiles demand tight tolerances, advanced material control, and tailored tooling expertise that only experienced extrusion
Embarking on a journey through the intricate world of custom foam creations, you'll quickly realize the paramount importance of precision and efficiency. A hot wire CNC foam cutter becomes an indispensable ally in this venture, delivering not just accuracy but also unparalleled ease and speed. As you explore the cutting edge foam cutting technology, imagine a heated wire gliding seamlessly through foam materials, rendering complex designs and flawless patterns that traditional manual cutting could never replicate. Whether you're crafting detailed
Industrial chillers are crucial in any setting that relies on heavy equipment with massive waste heat. They ensure safe and efficient operation in these types of settings. Chillers cool different equipment pieces and process fluids, as well as ambient temperatures.